problems with the apostolic church

2:16; 3:5). Pirate Christian Radio has documented fifty-two stories of people who have left NAR over charismania and deception. He has told us there would be many deceivers (2 John 1:7). [18] One might also add that they were verifiable (Acts 3:8-10). The church will only be strong when every member commits himself to the ministry that God has gifted him to do. In general, this movement can be characterized by six big ideas: postmillennialism, reconstructionism, manufactured continuationism, restorationism, experientialism and pragmatism. In wild deer and sage grouse, as in Mormon cults, polygyny is associated with high levels of inbreeding, because it shrinks the number of males contributing to the gene pool and increases the relatedness of the entire community. The church tried to meet these needs. The plain, normal reading of OT passages like Dan. But it does show there are people today who think they have the word of knowledge and/or the ability to receive divine revelation but really do not. These men had to be under the Spirits control. There is also the issue of conflicting words from the Lord. In Lizzys words, I had believed to have heard from the Lord that I was going to meet my future husband at this church. Leaders from her church confirmed her prophetic word. But after sharing it with her prospective husband (whom she barely knew) he replied that he believed God was telling him to pursue another young lady, that God told him to marry someone else[38] She reports that this experience is common. Please realize that all Apostolic or non-Apostolic churches should not be judged by experiences from the existence of a few bad churches in their ranks. But Gods way to deal with a problem is not to grumble amongst the body, and not to leave the church, but to go directly to the leaders who can listen and deal with the problem in a constructive manner. There is sufficient biblical and historical evidence to reject it. Christians are to radically oust the devil from spiritual strongholds through a variety of spiritual warfare activities. The Bible is our source of spiritual growth: we are supposed to desire the pure milk of the word [i.e., written revelation of the Bible], that you may grow thereby (1 Pet. Councils and their creeds. A controversial debate about racism in the United Pentecostal Church International is now raging in the denomination after an interracial couple who led one of (5) They had to be full of wisdom. In short, none has been gold. He was also able to obtain samples of gemstones from angels appearing in services and concluded they were synthetic man-made stones.[44] On another occasion a geochemist from the University of Toronto did an investigation of gold dust and found the specks did not contain any gold or platinum but were some type of plastic film.[45] And yet a third study by the U.S. Geological Survey found it was plastic film with no traces of gold, platinum or silver.[46]. Ilash, pastor of the Well of Living Water Church, Izmail, Ukraine, has been touring the Midwest telling people the churchs story. The Hellenistic Jews felt like their widows were being slighted, while the Hebrew widows were getting more than their fair share in the daily distribution of food. There is an intramural debate today among Christians as to which view is correct. Christians have a God-given duty to remain skeptical of anybody who claims to have the ability to receive revelation from God, especially when such revelation is said to be on par with OT prophets and NT apostles. Since the gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable (Rom. Neither could he heal Epaphroditus (Phil. In 2008, Glenn Smith admitted to planting gemstones to seed peoples faith in the supernatural work. However, there is some pre-tribulational support from these early writers as well (cf. In a remote region of the US, a town is struggling with a chilling health crisis caused by a recessive gene. Planting gemstones in a service might work for bringing a person to faith in Christ, but certainly the practice is not biblical. The laying on of hands symbolized the apostles giving recognition and approval to these capable men to carry on this aspect of ministry. They believe in the unity of the Godhead and the distinctions between the members of the Trinity. Years ago my office was at home. It was because they were trying to serve the Lord by meeting the needs of these widows that this conflict arose, not because they were worldly-minded and doing nothing about the problem. They would have been prone toward salvation by works or because of their Jewish birth. The passion for evangelization: the apostolic zeal of the believer. In contrast, the Church does recognize as valid the episcopal ordinations of the Eastern Orthodox Churches (CCC 1399) and the Polish National Church (see also the Code of Canon Law, can. Now Luke again turns inward, showing us this problem that occurred within the church at this time of unusual growth. Copyright, Steven J. Cole, 2001, All Rights Reserved. (4) They had to be full of the Spirit. In fact, only one of her cousins can walk. 5:23). To have been in the early church would have been a wonderful experience. Wagner points to statistics, viz., the rapid growth of NAR in Africa, Asia and Latin America, as evidence of its divine origin. [37] Why did God withhold the knowledge from C. Peter Wagner that his NAR World Prayer Center co-founder Ted Haggard was using drugs and having sex with male prostitutes? Heb. One Church Growth trend today is to plant churches that are targeted to reach only one segment of our society, such as the Generation Xers or the Baby Boomers. (2) They were plural in number. Why then do sincere pastors commit and condone spiritual fraud? For example, Rick Joyner and Bob Jones prophesied in 1997 that California would soon be destroyed by earthquakes and nuclear bombs. WebA. Consequently, metabolic disorders such a fumarase deficiency are particularly devastating to the organ. Mark Haville is a former faith-healer who confessed, I learned gradually to do what all these speakers like Copeland, Cerullo, Benny Hinn and others do. 12:30). Often they spend years trying to repent, hoping to get back into the religion, says Bistline, who has three brothers who were discarded. Jesus did not rebuke them like other times (cf. It must be taken from the world and given to the . Whenever you have growth through new conversions, you will have problems. The Bible does indeed describe the Christian embroiled in a spiritual war (Ephesians 6:12, 13). Hes been searching for some Ex-Mormon Christian support for a while, and one of his friends recommended Apologia Church to him since they have a popular Mormon ministry. Humanly speaking, they would have been the most difficult to reach. Pentecostal Church of Apostolic Faith (PCAF)-25,000 United Church of Jesus Christ (Apostolic) (UCJC-A)-100,000. Its shocking to discover that the Lords other servants do not all agree with my way of doing things! 15:6). Audrey Barrick, Joyce Meyers Ex-Bodyguard Convicted of Murder, The Christian Post, May 7, 2011. Leaving the Nar Church: Lizzys Story (Part 1), Pirate Christian Media, accessed July 8, 2018. Leaving the Nar Church (Search Results), Pirate Christian Media, accessed July 8, 2018. Leaving the Nar Church: Melanies Story, Pirate Christian Media, May 30, 2017, See comment 35 by Lillian Ching posted July 26, 2008 on Gemstones Fraud Glenn Smith Caught Redhanded!, End Times Prophetic, Prophecy, Visions, Dreams, Revelation, Christian Blog, accessed Oct 15, 2011,. Luke again turns to the church in the world, describing the apostles witness before the Sanhedrin, resulting in their being flogged. June 27, 2017.http://www.spiritoferror.org/2017/06/the-problem-with-the-firestarters-prophetic-activation-class-at-bethel-redding/6727. Today polygyny is more widespread in Africa than any other continent. Both groups in the Jerusalem church had come to faith in Jesus as Gods Messiah and Savior. With that said, in the midst of this, the bigger problem resides in the fact that their music tops the Christian music charts. Because of the psychosomatic effect, pharmaceutical companies must factor in the placebo when evaluating the effectiveness of their medications. The poor, then, present us with a great challenge: we must refuse to let the faith we profess be imprisoned by a piety removed from life, one that results in a kind of spiritual egotism, a spirituality of my own creation that serves to preserve my own inner tranquillity and complacency. Three times stand is used (Eph. Today its home to the twin towns of Hildale and Colorado City either side of the Utah-Arizona border and some 7,700 people. The Bible says it is a noble thing to check what people are teaching and compare it to the Word (Acts 17:11). Stephen, one of the seven men, was full of faith and of the Holy Spirit (6:5). New Kensington, PA: Whitaker House, 1996. And God cannot err either intentionally (an absolute moral law-giver cannot deceive) or unintentionally (because He is omniscient). That is a lifelong process. Brigham Young founded Salt Lake City in Utah (Credit: iStock). Members of the apostolic church are deeply religious and look to their minister for spiritual guidance in their daily lives. There are legitimate times to separate from professing Christians or churches, although that subject is beyond the scope of this message. Pivec, Holly. In Acts 3 through 4:22, we see the church again in the world, with the first instance of persecution. Joyner, Rick.A Prophetic Vision for the 21st Century: A Spiritual Map to Help You Navigate Into the Future. 9:7 (the zeal of the Lord will perform this) would be that it is God who will bring about His kingdom. People are dazzled with what they believe are wonderful and glorious works of God during worship services. Regarding salvation, they teach the need for conviction of sin, repentance, restitution, and confession for salvation. Union of Church and State. However, experience is a lousy test for truth according to the Bible and this is especially so if we are in the last days. Historically, the early church held to premillennialism. 3; Titus 2). Church leaders cite the Bible for this unusual modesty guideline, such as this verse from 1 Timothy 2:9: "I In this case, historic premillennialism wins to the peril of amillennialism and postmillennialism.[10]. Christians often naively get involved in serving the Lord with the assumption that everyone will get along since were all doing the Lords work. But often it is when we try to serve the Lord together that conflicts erupt, which never would have happened if we had not been serving the Lord. The congregation wisely chose seven men with Greek names, who probably were from Greek backgrounds. Popular leaders are said to be Bill Johnson (Bethel Church, Redding, CA), Mike Bickle,[3] Randy Clark, Todd Bentley, Bill Hamon and the late Fuller Seminary professor C. Peter Wager. With experientialism, experience is placed above the Word of God. [19] Vineyard claims that hundreds of people [are] healed every month. [20] However, when pressed, John Wimber gave an example of one woman who was eighty-percent healed of a condition and others who slowly recovered over time. Here is his list of truths that have been restored to date according to NAR teaching. Six broad values and beliefs of the movement are evaluated in the following order: postmillennialism, restorationism, manufactured continuationism, reconstructionism, experientialism and pragmatism. Nobody reading the early church fathers in their day would find this phrase confusing because the office of apostle did not exist anymorethe apostles always referred to the Twelve plus Paul. Though our brains account for just 2% of the bodys total weight, they are ravenously hungry using up around 20% of its energy supply. Prayer and the ministry of the Word are interrelated. WebThe Expansion of the Church | Reformed Bible Studies & Devotionals at Ligonier.org | Reformed Bible Studies & Devotionals at Ligonier.org. 1. 16:4). They manipulate audiences and individuals simply by the power of suggestion The techniques are no different to those used by any practicing hypnotist the people in these meetings are already coming with high expectancy They are psychological techniques nothing else.[27]. Jesus said the gate to destruction was broad, and there are many who go in by it (Matt. Pauls biblical charge is: Preach the word; be ready in season and out of season; reprove, rebuke, and exhort, with complete patience and teaching. ., ed.The New Apostolic Churches. Apostolic voices such as Fred Price and Bill McCartney What we do find is much attention given to the selection and qualifications of elders/bishops (same office) and deacons (1 Tim 3:1-13; Titus 1:5-9). Search conducted by querying the apostles in Logos Bible Software using Alexander Roberts, James Donaldson, and A. Cleveland Coxe, eds., Holly Pivec, The Problem with Bethel Reddings Firestarters Prophetic Activation Class, Part 1, Spirit of Error, June 27, 2017,. 2:2). The main Latin theology came primarily from such figures as Tertullian and Cyprian (bishop of Carthage, 248258) rather than from any figure in Rome. Catrina writes, We ladies had a morning of being taught how to prophesy. C. Peter Wagner is credited as one of the fathers of the NAR movement. WebThe Christ Apostolic Church, Agbala Itura, like any other corporate body or indeed any other Church had numerous problems from the beginning, and is still grappling with Sadly, the picture the Bible paints of the church in the end days is that most people will turn away from the sound doctrine of Scripture. It results in structural abnormalities and a syndrome including seizures and delayed development, says Narayanan. Truth be told, this shouldnt be controversial. For example, at a Firestarters class at Bethel Church in Redding, people are taught how to heal the sick and prophesy. Since it was perfected billions of years ago, the enzyme has become a staple of every living thing on the planet. The whole problem-solving process was oriented to God through prayer and Gods Word. Responding to Open Theism, http://www.elijahlist.com/words/display_word/257, https://www.doria.fi/bitstream/handle/10024/100059/laitinen_petri.pdf, http://www.spiritoferror.org/2017/06/the-problem-with-the-firestarters-prophetic-activation-class-at-bethel-redding/6727, http://piratechristian.squarespace.com/berean-examiner/2017/4/leaving-the-nar-church-catrinas-story, https://www.csicop.org/si/show/benny_hinn_healer_or_hypnotist, https://www.csicop.org/si/show/exposing_the_faith-healers, https://thewordonthewordoffaithinfoblog.com/2009/05/26/ex-faith-healer/, https://www.christianpost.com/news/joyce-meyers-ex-bodyguard-convicted-of-murder-50138/, https://bereanresearch.org/leaving-nar-church-lizzys-story-part-1/, http://www.piratechristian.com/berean-examiner/?tag=Leaving+the+NAR+Church, http://piratechristian.squarespace.com/berean-examiner/2017/5/-leaving-the-nar-church-melanies-story, https://web.archive.org/web/20111015064411/http:/endtimespropheticwords.wordpress.com/2008/01/11/gemstones-fraud-glenn-smith-caught-redhanded/, https://web.archive.org/web/20010410101417/http:/www.charismanews.com/news.cgi?a=145&t=news.html, https://www.maplevalleyreporter.com/news/maple-valley-deputy-mayor-glenn-smith-admits-to-planting-gemstones-at-phoenix-religious-meeting/, https://www.charismamag.com/~charisma/component/cm_videos/article/18-blogs/fire-in-my-bones/2942-strange-fire-in-the-house-of-the-lord?Itemid=171, https://www.facebook.com/joshuamillsglory/videos/1733116320034201/, http://www.apologeticsindex.org/2977-new-apostolic-reformation-overview, Water baptism, separation of church and state, Sanctification, the church set apart from the world, Evangelist ministry, evangelism with miraculous healings, Renewal of all restored truth to all past movement churches, Faith confessions, prosperity, and victorious attitude and life, Prophetic, activating gifts, warfare praise, prophets to nations, Apostolic, miraculous, networking, great harvest, Saints manifesting mightily, harvest reaped. The church is primarily an organismthe living body of which Christ is the head. All six beliefs and practices are unbiblical and should be avoided along with the movement itself. In response to his question which of all the sects Conservationists have known for years that a populations mating system the fancy word for sexual behaviour can have a profound impact on its genetics. 18:22). 1:22, 23) while the preaching of heresy reaches many (e.g., the rapid growth of the Christian cults). Do all speak with tongues? [6], In-depth analysis of the movement can be found in writings online and in print. I started in 2012 and finished in 2020. Today we have many books on church management, conflict resolution, and church growth that are based more on worldly wisdom than on Gods Word. I'm Dr. Shawn Nelson. Leaders cannot deal with problems that they do not know about. They are driven to the highway by their mothers in the middle of the night and dumped by the side of the road, says Amos Guiora, a legal expert at the University of Utah who has written a book about religious extremism. Peter preaches and 3,000 souls are saved. The NAR variety can be described as charismania, which will be explained later. Like all babies, spiritual babies are usually self-centered at first. When pressed to give reporters examples, he mentioned one girl who, turns out, had merely fainted in a church service. (5) Experientialism: manifestations of the Holy Spirit take priority and provide confirmation of the movements validity. The main thing to note is that to carry out this ministry that involved handling and distributing resources, these men had to be godly. In every case, the child had the same distinctive facial features, the same delayed development most couldnt sit up, let alone walk and, crucially, they were from the same region on the Arizona-Utah border, known as Short Creek. In other words, spirituality isnt limited to the soul, but also to the body. The poor, then, present us with a great challenge: we must refuse to let the faith we profess be imprisoned by a piety removed from life, one that results in a kind of spiritual egotism, a spirituality of my own creation that serves to preserve my own inner tranquillity and complacency. The key to resolving differences is for each person to recognize the validity of all the gifted members and to use his (or her) gift to work on the problems that he perceives. It is nave to think, Since were all born again, we wont experience any conflicts. Salvation does not eradicate different cultural assumptions and attitudes. Even with just one wife and three children, if every subsequent generation follows suit a man can have 243 descendants after just five generations. (2) Restorationism: the offices (not gift) of apostle and prophet were lost in the early church and must be restored. Spiritual people may glean some insights from such books. In Acts 2, we see the church in the world. Such a false prophet was to be put to death (Dt. Smith, Chuck.Charisma Vs. Charismania. In polygynous families this is supercharged. When I moved to Arizona thats when I realised that my colleagues here were probably the most familiar Id ever met with this disease, says Vinodh Narayanan, a neurologist at the Translational Genomics Research Institute, Arizona, who has treated several patients with fumarase deficiency. Jesus had this to say about sign-seekers: A wicked and adulterous generation seeks after a sign (Mt. Random genetic mutations become more important.. The requirement for these men who were to deal with the problem was that they be men of good reputation, full of the Spirit and wisdom (6:3). There is reason to be cautious about this too. 4:1). To sum up all of these principles: to solve problems in the local church, both leaders and people must be spiritual people in submission to Gods Word. Neither do we find the office of apostle in early church history. Filed in Current Projects, philosophy Project Topics by TMLT Editorials In contrast, when the healings of so-called miracle workers are examined today, they fall short of the NT description. They diagnosed fumarase deficiency, an inherited disorder of the metabolism. Brigham Young was a busy man. He was a passionate believer in the practice, which he announced as the official line of the church a few years earlier. They all have feeding tubes and need care 24 hours a day. 4:11-12 & 2 Tim. True spirituality is not impractical and other-worldly. 1 Apostolic Governance This is the belief that there is a restoration of modern-day apostles who function in the same capacity and with the same authority as The apostles here were willing to change the organizational structure of the church to meet this legitimate need. They were gifted and The mind can have such an influence on the body that one man laughed himself well of cancer.[26] A womans mind can convince her body that she is pregnant. This is thought to be how one-in-200 men (one in 12.5 in Asia) are descended directly from super-fertile Mongol warrior Genghis Khan, who died nearly eight centuries ago. Peter, Paul and John all retain this OT expectation throughout their writingsPeter in Acts 3:19-21, 24-25 and 2 Pet. Though Young began his adult life as a devoted spouse to a single wife, by the time he died his family had swelled to 55 wives and 59 children. 1:19)this speaks of inspiration. The ability to heal seemed to wane toward the end of Pauls life. Healthy churches maintain the balance of dealing with internal problems, but also staying focused on the task of taking the gospel to the world. Weve already seen the problem of hypocrisy, with Ananias and Sapphira. It was a sweltering summers day in Provo City, Utah and as he spoke, high winds swirled dust around him. There are examples of miracle workers outright faking miracles. There is nothing wrong with conducting church business according to Roberts Rules of Order, if people are not self-willed, not acting on the basis of worldly wisdom, not grabbing for power or influence. It would appear that Timothy and Titus faithfully carried out the desires of their mentor, Paul, and established bishop/elders and deacons instead. (7) Soaking: Soaking in Gods presence is accompanied by dreams, visions, trances, even visitations by angels and out-of-body experiences. (6) Pragmatism: whatever brings greater numerical results is thought to have been validated by God; NARs numerical success is thought to vouch for its credibility. If youre not discerning, you end up swallowing the whole thing. But to dwell below with the saints we know, well, thats a different story!. But getting saved did not erase all of these background factors. In fact, more human disease genes have been discovered in Utah with its Mormon history than any other place in the world. It was only with great difficulty that Marla finally persuaded her that I had no clue how that ministry was going, and if she really wanted to find out, she needed to call the woman who headed that program. WebUntil about 250, most Western Christian leaders (e.g., Irenaeus and Hippolytus) spoke Greek, not Latin. In an office several hundred miles from where Young gave his speech, a 10-year-old boy was presented to Theodore Tarby, a doctor specialising in rare childhood diseases. Even if one believes they are still in operation today, a good dose of skepticism should be in order. Orthodoxy is judged by how faithful a person or movement is to Scripture. This is called false pregnancy and it produces the same symptoms as a real-pregnancy (minus the baby). He liked to lead by example. You cannot properly preach the Word unless you wait upon God in prayer. The word of knowledge is either hopelessly unpractical or, more likely, these people are not really exercising the gift that is being described in the Bible. This kind of charismania is unbiblical. Instead, lineages begin to fold in on themselves as distant (and in the FLDS, not so distant) cousins marry. So we must commit ourselves to work through our problems whenever it does not compromise essential truth. The doctrine of the Apostolic Church is similar to most evangelical churches. In this small, isolated community of Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints (FLDS) a group that split from the LDS in the early 20th Century the likelihood of being born with fumarase deficiency is over a million times above the global average. In chapter one, the church is alone, gathered for prayer in the upper room, where they elect an apostle to replace Judas. Haville, Mark, and Peter Glover. NAR teaches there is an abundance of new revelation available today: There are going to be those in the end time generation who will have Daniel-types of revelatory experiences.[31] However, these revelatory experiences are said to be a different type of revelation: a revelation that can err and fail from people whose accuracy is said to increase over time (the best of the NAR prophets are said to only be sixty-six percent accurate). Thats because genetic information is useless on its own. The Bible has a special concern for widows and orphans (see 1 Tim. Of course, this does not prove these supernatural gifts have ceased. Shifting Shadows Series. Leaving the Nar Church: Catrinas Story, Pirate Christian Media, April 6, 2017, Joe Nickell, Benny Hinn: Healer or Hypnotist?, The Committee for Skeptical Inquiry, accessed July 8, 2018,. To get to grips with why its plaguing Short Creek, first we need to back to the mid-19th Century. Loren thinks the reason is because most are ambitious to build a great ministry reputation and expand their opportunities for itinerant ministry as well.[52], Of course, a few forgeries do not prove every manifestation is false. Tertullian wrote Against Praxeas, in which he discussed the doctrines of the Trinity and the person of [23] Perhaps the most embarrassing was in 1986 when Peter Popoff was caught using a wireless earpiece to dupe his audience into thinking he had the power of God to heal. April 10, 2001. https://web.archive.org/web/20010410101417/http:/www.charismanews.com/news.cgi?a=145&t=news.html. Nevertheless, Bible students have good reason to believe that Christ will return physically and establish a real, physical kingdom in Jerusalem where he will rule the nations (see esp. The word of knowledge is related in practice to prophetic revelation. Strong NAR teachers like Rick Joyner and Bill Johnson are featured at IHOP; see note 8. Its so important, today the instructions for making it are remarkably similar across all species, from owls to orchids. Nonetheless, apparently there were only two among them who met the qualifications of having physically accompanied Peter and the other ten beginning from the baptism of John to that day when He was taken up from us (Acts 1:21-22). We are not told whether the Hellenistic Jews went directly to the apostles and discussed this problem, or whether the apostles heard about it through the grapevine. The implication is that the crowd can be wrong. WebThe Roman Catholic Church has not entirely denied apostolic succession to non-Roman churches. It turned out his sister, whom the couple believed was suffering from cerebral palsy, had it too. Four students who had never prophesied were told to stand on the platform to be activated into the prophetic gift.[14] They were then told to prophesy in front of the class. Spiritual Gifts According to C. Peter Wagner. diss., Abo Akademi University, 2014.https://www.doria.fi/bitstream/handle/10024/100059/laitinen_petri.pdf. Which brings us to the good news. 4:1-5) has been one of my main directional verses in ministry. The boy had unusual facial features, including a prominent forehead, low-set ears, widely spaced eyes and a small jaw. 844.2). 4:20). The Greek word refers to males. Instead, Jesus simply answered, It is not for you to know times or seasons which the Father has put in His own authority. (Acts 1:7). Here, polygamy is still practised. When the disciples asked Jesus at the end of his ministry, Lord, will You at this time restore the kingdom to Israel? (Acts 1:6) they most certainly were thinking of a physical kingdom like all Jews of their day. NAR can also be characterized by experientialism. 24:4, 11). 3:1) and this expectation continued through the time of Christ. It is debatable whether this event was from the Lord since the one they chose is never heard from again. Let us continue our catechesis on the witnesses of apostolic zeal. He does not act with human or worldly wisdom, but in accordance with the wisdom revealed in Scripture. In the FLDS, a large proportion of men must be kicked out as teenagers, shrinking the gene pool even further. [54] Whatever brings greater numerical results is thought to be validated by God. Colorado City is one of the two towns where the remote community live (Credit: iStock). We were told to tell ourselves, Im going to start prophesying, even if I have to start in the flesh.[16], Not only does the Holy Spirit decide which gift(s) people get but the Bible says the exercising of the gift(s) is done by the power of the Holy Spirit. But unless there are biblical grounds to separate, God is glorified when people from diverse cultures and backgrounds worship Him together on the common ground of salvation through Jesus Christ. Leaving the Nar Church: Melanies Story. May 30, 2017. http://piratechristian.squarespace.com/berean-examiner/2017/5/-leaving-the-nar-church-melanies-story. Bloomington, MN: Baker Book House, 2012. 8:27; 1 Cor. If not, where is the balance between elder rule versus congregational government. 12). Despite claims to the contrary, the Bible puts a premium on knowledge of Scripture.

Keith Thomas Subway, Articles P